Court rulings on candidates raise concerns over voters’ sovereignty – Businessday NG

…Latest judgments put INEC’s preparations in jeopardy

Nigeria’s growing reliance on the judiciary to determine candidates and winners of elections is raising concerns about the credibility of the electoral system, with analysts warning that court interventions could undermine public confidence in democracy and the people’s right to choose their leaders.

The concerns come amid a series of court rulings affecting political parties’ nominations ahead of the 2027 general elections, including the recent nullification of former Vice President Atiku Abubakar’s nomination as the African Democratic Congress (ADC) presidential candidate.

A Federal High Court in Abuja, presided over by Justice Peter Lifu, last week invalidated Atiku’s nomination and the David Mark-led ADC National Working Committee, ruling that the caretaker committee was unlawfully constituted.

The ADC has announced plans to appeal the judgment, which could affect the participation of one of the major opposition figures in the presidential election.

Analysts have warned that Atiku’s exclusion from the ballot could trigger widespread violence, particularly in northern Nigeria, where he commands significant political support.

The ruling has renewed debate about the extent to which judicial decisions should influence electoral outcomes and whether the courts are increasingly becoming the final arbiters of political power.

Other recent judgments have also affected candidates and party nominations.

Read also: Court orders INEC to reinstate Adebutu on Ogun gubernatorial list

A Federal High Court in Abuja, presided over by Justice Obiora Egwuatu, nullified Governor Hope Uzodimma’s nomination as the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for Imo West Senatorial District and directed the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to recognise former governor Rochas Okorocha as the authentic candidate.

In Niger State, the Federal High Court in Minna set aside the APC nomination for Mokwa/Lavun/Edati Federal Constituency in favour of Adamu Usman and directed the ADC to recognise Abubakar Shehu for Kontagora/Wushishi/Mariga/Mashegu Federal Constituency.

The Supreme Court also restored provisions of the Electoral Act 2026 relating to party membership registers, upholding the enforceability of registers submitted to INEC before primaries.

The judgment led to the omission of some candidates, including Ladi Adebutu, the Ogun State PDP governorship candidate, from INEC’s list for the 2027 elections.

The development has revived concerns about the role of courts in determining political participation, particularly when disputes over party membership and nomination procedures ultimately affect candidates’ eligibility.

The controversy is not new

Following the 2019 general elections, the Supreme Court nullified Emeka Ihedioha’s election as Imo State governor and declared Uzodimma, who had originally placed fourth, the winner.

In Zamfara State, the court nullified the victories of APC candidates, including the governorship and legislative positions, over the party’s failure to conduct valid primaries. It subsequently declared PDP candidates, who were runners-up, winners.

In Bayelsa State, the Supreme Court nullified David Lyon’s election as governor-elect barely 24 hours before his inauguration over false information and forged credentials presented by his deputy, Biobarakuma Degi-Erimienyo. The court consequently declared Douye Diri of the PDP, who had secured the next highest number of lawful votes and met the constitutional requirements, the winner.

These decisions have intensified debate over whether judicial intervention is protecting electoral integrity or increasingly determining outcomes that voters believe they have settled at the ballot.

Section 14(2)(a) of the 1999 Constitution establishes that sovereignty belongs to the people of Nigeria, while international democratic instruments recognise popular participation through universal suffrage as a fundamental basis of government.

Chidi Odinkalu, former chairman of the National Human Rights Commission, argued at a recent public forum that although courts have a legitimate constitutional responsibility to interpret electoral laws and resolve disputes, electoral jurisprudence in Nigeria has increasingly allowed judicial decisions to alter outcomes and determine who receives the mandate to govern.

“The jurisprudence of election petitions and political cases in Nigeria can no longer be justified in many ways,” Odinkalu said.

He questioned whether popular sovereignty remained meaningful when courts could “expropriate and confiscate” from citizens their constitutional role in determining who should receive the mandate to rule.

“If we end up in a situation where, as a matter of practice, elections end up in the hands of lawyers, discussed as pleadings, and settled on the basis of traversal or non-traversal, it has become perverse, it is no longer an election, and we’ve got to decide whether we are still interested in elections.”

OlaOluwa Braithwaite, executive director of the Tunji Braithwaite Foundation, also questioned whether the judicial process had displaced the ballot as the decisive instrument of electoral choice.

“Have we, by default, created a system where elections are won not at the ballot but in the courtroom?” she asked.

Oludotun Adefope-Okojie, a retired judge, blamed politicians for repeatedly seeking judicial intervention and criticised the use of legal technicalities to overturn election outcomes.

“I have consistently said that all these technicalities that are being used to void elections, it must stop. The will of the people must prevail,” she said.

Over 1,200 petitions were reportedly filed with election tribunals following the 2023 general elections, covering presidential, governorship, and legislative races.

Cumulative figures historically show thousands of petitions across election cycles (for instance, data from preceding election cycles up to 2019 recorded thousands of filings, such as 3,959 across five general elections from 1999 to 2019), making the cumulative figure since 2003 exceeding 5,000 plausible when factoring in subsequent cycles.

The debate raises a fundamental question ahead of 2027: how can Nigeria preserve the judiciary’s constitutional role in resolving electoral disputes without allowing legal proceedings to undermine public confidence in the ballot as the ultimate expression of popular sovereignty?

Read also: Netizen warns Amupitan over 2027 election, says Yakubu will be last INEC Chairman to survive rigging allegations

INEC’s preparations in jeopardy

The lingering court cases and the judgments are seen to jeopardise preparations for the INEC for the elections. Observers have raised the concern that critical activities that should have been completed or near-completion are being delayed unnecessarily as a result of the back-and-forth movements of the courts on political matters.

“I see a situation where the INEC Chairman will come up at the end of the election in 2027 to tell Nigerians that the exercise failed the expectations because of late printing of the ballot papers and other necessary materials as a result of the judicial rascality the country is witnessing now. Time is of essence,” Lawrence Bassey, a public affairs analyst, said.

Related News

Taofeek Oyedokun

Taofeek Oyedokun is a correspondent at BusinessDay with years of experience reporting on political economy, public policy, migration, environment/climate change, and social justice. A graduate of Political Science from the University of Lagos, he has also earned multiple professional certificates in journalism and media-related training. Known for his clear, data-driven reporting, Oyedokun covers a wide range of national and international socioeconomic issues, bringing depth, balance, and public-interest focus to his work.

Advertisement

Source:

Businessday NG