INEC’s credibility crisis threatens confidence in 2027 election – Businessday NG

The credibility of Nigeria’s 2027 general elections is facing an early test as growing public distrust in the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), allegations of voter register manipulation and questions over the commission’s neutrality threaten to undermine confidence in the electoral process.

The concerns are particularly significant as the country approaches the January 16 presidential and federal legislative elections and February 6 governorship and state assembly polls, with analysts warning that an election conducted without public confidence in its umpire could deepen political tensions and weaken democratic legitimacy.

The latest indication of the growing distrust emerged on November 12 when protesters in London blocked the vehicle of Joash Amupitan, INEC chairman, outside Chatham House, describing the Commission as a “criminal organisation” and demanding the chairman’s resignation.

The protesters alleged that INEC was biased in favour of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu and the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC), citing alleged irregularities in the preliminary voters’ register, including duplicate entries and suspected artificial intelligence-generated photographs.

Although reports dismissed the demonstration as involving a small group of protesters and alleged that some were being paid, the incident reflects the difficult task facing the electoral Commission as it attempts to rebuild confidence ahead of the elections.

The challenge is not entirely new. Before the 2023 general election, Afrobarometer polling showed that only 23 percent of Nigerians trusted INEC somewhat or a lot, while 78 percent expressed little or no trust in the commission.

Amupitan, who assumed office in October 2025, acknowledged at Chatham House that INEC had not fully recovered from the credibility crisis surrounding the 2023 election.

Defending his leadership, he pointed to the timely declaration of results in the Anambra and Osun elections and the 2026 Ekiti governorship poll, where Yiaga Africa said the official results aligned with its independent estimates, despite concerns about vote buying.

“My loyalty is solely to the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria and the Electoral Act,” Amupitan said, insisting that constitutional institutions must operate within the rule of law.

However, critics argue that recent controversies surrounding the Commission have done little to address longstanding concerns about its transparency and independence.

One major source of anxiety is the 2026 national voters’ register, which contains 103,428,715 registered voters following the Continuous Voter Registration exercise that generated 11,088,238 records.

After the register was displayed for public scrutiny, Nigerians raised concerns about duplicate entries, deceased voters, unusual names and suspected AI-generated photographs.

In November, INEC announced the removal of 1,608,660 invalid registration records following biometric verification and 268,000 public complaints.

The commission further disclosed that 54 staff members across 10 states were implicated in bypassing registration controls and abusing exemptions provided for persons with disabilities.

While the disciplinary action suggests an effort to address internal weaknesses, the absence of detailed geographical and categorical breakdowns of the deleted records has fuelled demands for an independent audit.

MundX Analytics, an election data and technology platform, questioned INEC’s decision to retain exclusive responsibility for verifying the integrity of the register.

“INEC cannot be the sole institution responsible for compiling, maintaining, cleaning and verifying the integrity of the same register without independent scrutiny. You cannot be a judge in your own case,” the platform said.

Regional disparities in registration figures have also raised concerns, particularly allegations of an 85 percent increase in registrations in a ward in Ebonyi State. Although Amupitan said the complaint had been investigated and resolved, opposition parties have continued to demand a forensic audit.

Beyond the register, questions about INEC’s neutrality have been reinforced by disagreements over the recognition of leadership factions within the African Democratic Congress and controversy surrounding an alleged pro-Tinubu social media account reportedly linked to the chairman’s phone number. INEC denied ownership of the account and said a forensic review cleared the chairman, but the decision to refer the matter to security agencies without disclosing the expert involved has left questions unresolved.

For Sam Amadi, director of the Abuja School of Social and Political Thought, the consequences of the credibility deficit could extend beyond the conduct of the elections.

Read also: Netizen warns Amupitan over 2027 election, says Yakubu will be last INEC Chairman to survive rigging allegations

“You cannot conduct an election when INEC lacks public trust,” Amadi said.

“Given the controversies surrounding the 2023 election, one would have expected the INEC Chairman to prioritise rebuilding public confidence. Instead, INEC’s actions over the past six months appear to have further damaged its credibility. This is dangerous for Nigeria because when citizens lose faith in the electoral process, they may resort to self-help, with potentially violent consequences.”

The concerns are compounded by provisions of the Electoral Act 2026, which civil society groups say leave room for manipulation in electronic transmission of results.

Although the law provides for electronic transmission to INEC’s Result Viewing Portal (IReV), it retains physical Form EC8A as the authoritative document when electronic transmission fails, without clearly defining failure or establishing penalties for deliberate disruptions.

This has revived memories of the 2023 elections, when only 31.8 percent of polling-unit results had been uploaded to IReV within 36 hours, despite expectations of real-time transmission.

To restore confidence, civil society organisations called for an independent audit of the voters’ register. They also called for binding rules defining transmission failures and the circumstances under which physical result sheets can override electronic records.

Read also: Cap-gate: INEC Chairman’s London trip overshadowed by APC cap controversy

INEC has announced plans for a November 28 mock election, improved storage of election materials, reduced voter limits per Bimodal Voter Accreditation System device and cryptographic verification of electronic result sheets.

However, experts argue that technological improvements alone will not resolve the problem if the commission does not demonstrate transparency and accountability.

The credibility of the 2027 elections will depend not only on INEC’s ability to deploy technology and deliver results on schedule but also on whether Nigerians believe the process is impartial, transparent and capable of reflecting their choices.

Without that confidence, even a technically successful election could struggle to command public acceptance, leaving the legitimacy of the next government vulnerable to disputes, political instability and declining faith in democratic institutions.

Related News

Taofeek Oyedokun

Taofeek Oyedokun is a correspondent at BusinessDay with years of experience reporting on political economy, public policy, migration, environment/climate change, and social justice. A graduate of Political Science from the University of Lagos, he has also earned multiple professional certificates in journalism and media-related training. Known for his clear, data-driven reporting, Oyedokun covers a wide range of national and international socioeconomic issues, bringing depth, balance, and public-interest focus to his work.

Advertisement

Source:

Businessday NG